Icing Call, Then Silence

Orange alert sign with the word 'ALERT' displayed prominently
Photo: Oualiid / Shutterstock

A pilot flying six people home from a weekend trip radioed air traffic control with two words no one wants to hear in midair: ice buildup.

Story Snapshot

  • A Piper PA-46 Malibu crashed near Wisconsin Dells, killing all six people on board, including one child.
  • The pilot reported icing at 24,000 feet and asked to descend before losing contact with controllers.
  • Flight tracking shows the plane entered a tightening right turn before data and radio contact disappeared.
  • The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) says a final cause determination could take up to two years.

What Happened In The Final Minutes Of The Flight

The single-engine Piper PA-46 Malibu left Kenosha, Wisconsin, headed for Menominee, Michigan, carrying six people on board. At 24,000 feet, the pilot told air traffic control he was dealing with ice and asked to drop to a lower altitude. Controllers approved the request right away. What followed was a descent that investigators say turned deadly fast.

According to the NTSB, the plane entered a right-hand turn that kept getting steeper. The rate of the turn increased until both radio communication and flight-tracking data cut out entirely. Moments later, the aircraft went down in Sauk County, killing everyone aboard. Five adults and one child died in the crash, with no survivors reported at the scene.

Investigators later identified the six victims as Ronald R. Riek, Tyler J. Harvey, Mary K. Brion, Amanda M. Haremza, Rylan Haremza, and Kayla C. Turpin. Family members have described the group as multiple generations traveling together, a detail that has hit hard in the small Wisconsin communities now mourning their loss.

Why Icing At High Altitude Is A Known Danger

Weather data backs up the pilot’s concern. The National Weather Service’s icing product showed a 50 percent chance of icing conditions near the crash site at the time, with pockets of light to moderate ice possible along the route. That figure doesn’t prove ice coated the wings, but it shows the pilot’s warning matched real conditions in the sky that day.

Ice buildup on a small plane’s wings and tail can quietly steal lift and throw off how the aircraft handles, even when a pilot barely notices it happening. NTSB safety records point to a recurring pattern: pilots who fly into icing without strictly following their aircraft’s deicing procedures, including keeping airspeed up and periodically checking the autopilot, have ended up in loss-of-control accidents before. Historical NTSB data covering 1990 through 2000 found that roughly a quarter of all icing-related accidents during that span involved deaths.

The Investigation Is Still Far From Finished

The NTSB has taken the lead on the investigation and says it isn’t speculating about what caused the crash while the on-scene work continues. That’s standard practice. A full determination of probable cause typically takes 12 to 24 months, meaning the public won’t get a definitive answer anytime soon.

Later reporting added another wrinkle: the pilot apparently also reported radio trouble and uncertainty about the plane’s heading, altitude, and airspeed before the descent turned into a spiral. That doesn’t contradict the icing report. It simply means investigators have more than one thread to pull as they rebuild what happened in those final minutes.

Investigators will now dig into the wreckage for physical evidence, including whether the plane’s deicing equipment was installed and working, and whether instrument problems started before or after the aircraft lost control. Maintenance logs, radar data, and recovered components from the crash site will all factor into the final report once it’s complete.

A Tragedy That Deserves A Full Accounting

Six people got on a plane expecting to land safely at home. A pilot’s calm, clear warning about ice gave controllers a chance to help, and they responded immediately by clearing a lower altitude. That the outcome still turned fatal is a gut punch for every family involved, and it’s exactly why the NTSB’s methodical, evidence-first process matters. Rushing to a conclusion would do a disservice to the victims and to every pilot who flies through icy skies afterward.

Sources:

foxnews.com, channel3000.com, cbsnews.com, nbc26.com, perthnow.com.au